Kuro5hin.org: technology and culture, from the trenches
create account | help/FAQ | contact | links | search | IRC | site news
[ Everything | Diaries | Technology | Science | Culture | Politics | Media | News | Internet | Op-Ed | Fiction | Meta | MLP ]
We need your support: buy an ad | premium membership

[P]
Zazen: The Fundamental Meditation of Zen

By jjayson in Culture
Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 09:32:33 PM EST
Tags: etc (all tags)
/etc

Zazen is the fundamental practice of Zen Buddhism. It is an form of meditation that focusing on living in the moment and being undisturbed by unnecessary thought and attachment. In various forms, it has spread from India through China, to Japan and now to the West. This is my attempt to provide you with what I have learned through experience and others, hopefully giving you enough to try it yourself.

Zazen has helped me relax, remove stress, and deal with stressful situations as they occur. I have noticed a large change in attentiveness to others, and I now notice the small things that I never used to, such as: when somebody changes their hair or when they wear something new. I speak slower, listen better, and generally communicate better with others. A true selflessness does come from zazen practice that is hard to qualify.


"To study the Buddha Way is to study the self, to study the self is to forget the self, and to forget the self is to be enlightened by the thousand things." — Master Dogen

"When the mind rests on nothing, true mind appears." — Diamond Sutra

The Zen school of Buddhism developed in China about one thousand years after Shakyamuni Buddha lived. It is practice of awareness, not a philosophy or theology. It is about being present in the now, just as the now is.

The fundamental practice of Zen Buddhism is zazen meditation. Zazen literally means "sitting zen" or "sitting concentration." It is a form of meditation where you try to concentrate on the now while sitting motionless, speechless, and thoughtless. In it you become completely focused on the moment. The mind is pacified, without complications and fear. Selfishness diminishes; compassion and wisdom come. Zen is about having time for the self. By reaching the deepest part of you, you can notice what brings you happiness and unhappiness and change your way of looking at things. It will reveal what you are letting crowd your thoughts, how hungry you are, if you are sleepy, and other changes in your body, making you mindful of the self. Yet, sitting in zazen is to be beyond thinking. Biologically through zazen, your cardiac and respiratory functions are regularized. Your brain reacts to stimuli, but quickly returns to the rhythm of zazen, collapsing your brain's waves to slow alpha and rythmic theta waves [alternate reference], and stress does no develop.

Start by giving yourself small islands of time each day, gradually growing, hopefully to 24 hours of zazen. Even five to ten minutes is good to start with. Select a quiet place away from distractions: telephone, television, radio, and others. Zazen can be practiced at any time in the day that is best for you. Some find it best practiced after getting out of the shower and your are loose, refreshed, and not tired.

Use something soft to sit on. In Japan they use a thick round cushion called a zafu, while in Tibet they use square mats. However, any cushion, pillow, or rolled-up blanket will work. Dress in loose clothing or at least loosen the clothes you have on by removing belts and unbuttoning pants.

Posture

Zen grows out of the idea that there is little distinction between the mental and the physical, so that by sitting with a straight aligned spine and being physically still, it will support the mind in settling and focusing. Because of this belief, a large emphasis is placed on posture and what helps to hold correct posture which will then hold correct thought. Indian Yogis first knew of sitting cross-legged for meditation. It is hard to fall asleep that way and less tiring than standing. There are several ways to sit on the floor, as well as ways to sit in a chair or lying down. However, all the classic postures involve a stable three-point base: each knee and your sitting bones.

The simplest position is called the Burmese position. The legs crossed by placing the first foot between the opposite thigh and groin, then the next foot is placed in contact with the shin. Both feet should be on the floor and well as the knees. This is one of the best positions for those just starting. The common full-lotus position is where each foot is on top of the opposing thigh. It is symmetric, solid, and efficient. It originated as a yogic position in India, but it requires some good flexibility. You should not attempt to force the full-lotus as it will be painful and can result in injury. There is also a half-lotus position where one foot is on the opposite thigh and the other foot is tucked under. Its asymmetry makes it difficult to remain relaxed while trying to hold the body symmetric. The full-lotus is preferred to the half-lotus because in it, the legs don't move out of position when they are deeply tucked; while in the half-lotus the legs can move, misaligning the upper body.

Tip the pelvis forward to help the knees touch the floor. If they are not, sitting on the edge of a cushion will lift the bottom higher and allow the knees to naturally drop. Push the knees against the floor, picture pushing your head against the ceiling, then relax into position. If the knees will not touch the floor, then try a higher cushion or try to place cushions under the knees. It is common for the legs to fall asleep, but if they are numb for more than a few seconds after standing up, then too much pressure was placed on the nerves in the legs, and sitting closer to the edge of the cushion will help this too.

"If one's body is straight, one's mind is easily straightened too. If one sits keeping one's body upright, one's mind does not become dull. One must be aware when one's mind runs around in distraction, or when one's body leans or sways, and allow body and mind to return to sitting upright." — Dogen Zenji

It is most important to keep the spine straight. Keep the back straight to allow the diaphragm to move easily. The spine should be in a natural S-curve, centered on a base above the bottom. Rock side-to-side slowly diminishing, from a wide arc to smaller arcs, to center the spine. To assist in getting that nice S-curve, slightly thrust forward the diaphragm while pulling your head back and tucking your chin. This way, the chest is kept open. Don't become tense and rigid. Picture yourself like a puppet hanging from the ceiling. Find a position that is comfortable to you. Never hurt yourself, and don't get caught up in the position. The mind is more important than the body.

If sitting cross-legged doesn't work, try kneeling-style with your knees together and sitting on your feet with cushions piled between your feet or on a small bench that can be purchased. You can also sit on the front of a chair with the feet flat on the floor, using cushions to vary your height, if necessary. Support the back instead of leaning against the chair. Another alternative, if you have disability problems, is to lie down on the back with the knees bent so the feet are flat.

The position of the hands is very important to zazen. Hold them in each other, parallel, so that the knuckles and fingers overlap. The thumb tips should be slightly touching, forming an ellipse. Hold the edge of the hands against the abdomen so that the thumbs are navel high. So not rest the hands on the feet, as sometimes this will pull the shoulders down, while holding the hands up will allow you to be mindful. The shoulders and arms should be relaxed. Pay attention to the hands and thumbs. They will tell you how you are doing. If you are drifting, the thumbs will also drift apart. If you are tense, the thumbs will push against each other too hard and form a peak. If one side of the body is higher than the other or one shoulder is tense, the ellipse will be lopsided.

Keeping the head level, very slightly pull the chin back, bringing the ears over the shoulders. Pulling the chin too far back will produce tension that you will feel in your neck. The mouth should be closed. The tongue should be held gently to the roof of the mouth. This will prevent salivation and the need to swallow as much. The teeth should be touching lightly to prevent the mind from talking. Breath in from the nose, expanding and filling the lower lungs down to the diaphragm. Exhale through the nose, deflating the lungs. Breath at a natural cadence and do not try to control it. Look down at a 95 degree angle, so you look about a meter in front of you. Only the gaze should be down, not the head. Blink a few times and let the eyelids naturally fall slightly open, enough to let in light. This will prevent falling asleep and dreaming. Try to unfocus your eyes.

Now that you are in correct position, work on correct thought. Take a few deep breaths, then let the breathing go at its natural pace. Feel your body for a few seconds: feel the rise and fall near your diaphragm; feel your spine and back; feel the air come in your nose, down into your lungs, and then leave your body. Be as still as possible. Then concentrate on the now: not your posture, not your breathing, not bills you have to pay, not a problem from work, not what is in front of you, nothing. Do not concentrated on any particular object or try to control your thoughts. However, be mindful of everything that is around you and do not drift off. As a thought comes, let it pass, making no judgement. Do not struggle with it; just leave it alone. It will only stay as long as you attach to it. If thoughts recur, let them come and go as they please. This is not failure. Don't try to use zazen to suppress thoughts that need to occur. Essential to zazen is to awaken from distraction and return to right thought in each moment.

After zazen your legs can become tense, stiff, and asleep. Kinhin, a form of walking after zazen, can be used to stretch them after or between long periods of time practicing zazen. It is zazen in motion: walking meditation. In Kinhin, everything above the waist is as in zazen. However, you walk in a slow motion with short steps, breathing synchronously with each step: in on one step and out on the next step. In Kinhin still strive for correct posture and correct thought. It is not a break from zazen, merely a different form.

Concentration

Concentrating and emptying the mind is very difficult, and when beginning, it can be maddeningly difficult. A good beginning for many people is to count the breaths. Focus your attention on each breath counting starting from one and going to ten, then repeating. Some people restart at one whenever they have a stray thought that enters the mind. Don't worry if you cannot get very high — some days you will not get past one. Eventually, this is abandoned when the concentration grows. This is real zazen, don't think of it as practice for the real thing.

When a thought enters your mind, picture it floating away as a cloud or as if on a river. This helps some people to not attach to thoughts and more freely let go.

If you are having trouble clearing the mind of random thoughts, another technique is whenever a though enters the mind, try to think of as many related thoughts as quickly as you can. You will soon run out of related thoughts and the mind will become blank. Over time you wear your mind down and then can truly concentrate on the self in the now.

Since we are social animals, group activity is important to us, as well as individual meditation. Try to find a meditation center near you to speak and learn from others. It will also keep you motivated for the entire time you practice zazen. Zen is practiced in more than zazen; Zen is practiced in daily life by letting moments come and go as they are and living in each of those moments. Learn this through zazen and try to apply it to all moments.

[[ More Pictures of Positions: Full-lotus, Full-lotus from angle, Half-lotus, Burmese, Sitting-bench ]]

Sponsors

Voxel dot net
o Managed Hosting
o VoxCAST Content Delivery
o Raw Infrastructure

Login

Poll
Have you even practiced Zazen? If not, will you now try?
o Yes, I have practiced before. 43%
o No, but I will try. 39%
o No, and I will not try. 16%

Votes: 114
Results | Other Polls

Related Links
o collapsing your brain's waves to slow alpha and rythmic theta waves
o alternate reference
o Burmese position
o full-lotus position
o half-lotus position
o natural S-curve
o cushions piled between your feet
o small bench
o position of the hands
o Full-lotus
o Full-lotus from angle
o Half-lotus
o Burmese
o Sitting-be nch
o Also by jjayson


Display: Sort:
Zazen: The Fundamental Meditation of Zen | 208 comments (168 topical, 40 editorial, 0 hidden)
The swinging door (4.28 / 7) (#7)
by phliar on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 04:43:48 PM EST

When I started zazen, I was told that one way to start is to visualise the mind as a swinging door, that swings in and out with each breath. It was easier to do this than to immediately start by trying to clear the mind of any attachment to thoughts.

A couple of passages I find interesting:

Let your mind be as clear as night. Thoughts will flash, like distant lightning. Simply watch and let them pass. Neither cling to them nor attempt to avoid them.

Fundamentally, no Bodhi tree exists;
Nor the frame of a mirror bright.
Since all is voidness from the beginning,
Where can the dust alight?


Faster, faster, until the thrill of...

Selfishness and the empty mind (4.14 / 7) (#19)
by El Volio on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 06:15:49 PM EST

Selfishness diminishes; compassion and wisdom come. Zen is about having time for the self.
This seems to me to be on the verge of contradiction. Does not selfishness diminish by taking an active interest in others? Compassion, or fellow feeling, should likewise come from trying to understand and sympathize with others. Those qualities in a person should be developed by spending less time focused on the self and more time focused on others, especially showing interest in them and genuinely trying to help them. This is not to say that improving the self does not result in more compassion and selflessness, but the focus in that case should be outward, not inward.

Additionally, I fail to understand how freeing one's mind of all thought will improve concentration. This is distinct from simply relaxing and trying not to focus on matters that would cause concern or stress of any sort. Just as a muscle must be exercised strenuously and then allowed time to recover, so our minds as well cannot spend every waking hour intensely focusing on some matter. But I am not convinced that to completely empty one's mind will provide the sort of rest needed; a good analogy might be the heart that must be exercised regularly but still beat at all times. Likewise, the mind must be exercised, but "freeing" it from all conscious thought does not accomplish the goal of simply resting it. There are many ways to be able to withdraw from complex thought (the mind's equivalent of rest while not sleeping) without completely avoiding any thought whatsoever.

Personally, I find meditation (traditional, not "transcendent") to be valuable for this. For me personally, that might mean spending time contemplating some abstract thought separate from day-to-day concerns or perhaps meditating on some spiritual matter. There have been days where my stress level was such that I needed to avoid considering any matters of even minimal complexity or depth for a time of relaxation at the end of the day, but this can be done without attempting to completely empty my mind.

If someone wishes to pursue zazen meditation or some other method of clearing his mind, then that's certainly his decision. It just seems counterproductive to me.

heh (2.83 / 6) (#26)
by xriso on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 06:55:47 PM EST

It seems a lot like this: "X is good. Zazen is good. Therefore, Zazen makes X happen. To do zazen, sit like this. Zazen is scientific and mystical."
--
*** Quits: xriso:#kuro5hin (Forever)
Zazen and me (4.83 / 6) (#29)
by phliar on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 07:01:10 PM EST

You might not be interested in my experiences with zazen, but I am interested in yours; I'm hoping this comment will bring out some personal experiences.

My first introduction to Zen was as a freshman in college; when we got drunk, we'd read koans to each other and laught uproariously, making fun of these stupid people and their stupid pointless stories. However, over the years I guess I started reading more about Zen, and five years later, I was in grad school and a friend recommended a Zen meditation center. Zazen was fun, and released a lot of the dissertation stress. The couplet by Hui-Neng I wrote in an earlier message:

Fundamentally, no Bodhi tree exists
Nor the frame of a mirror bright.
Since all is voidness from the beginning
Where can the dust alight?
I found it appealing. A friend wrote it for me in Kanji calligraphy; I scanned it in and made it the last page of my PhD dissertation. (It was in computer science.)

Skip sixteen years and we get to the present. Alas, time pressures make it impossible for me to go to a meditation center, so I practice zazen on my own. It helped me gain perspective on my fears and insecurities. I have a tendency to obsess on the worst possible outcome of any decision point; zazen gave me the control I needed to move my mind away from the route. Recently I have been diagnosed with depression with slight bipolar tendencies (mania). I don't yet know whether zazen will be helpful. I plan to try it, and of course I plan to keep my psychiatrist fully informed.

(I also have really bad knees from years of running, cycling and skiing; the full lotus position is now excruciatingly painful!)


Faster, faster, until the thrill of...

Meditation. (2.20 / 10) (#33)
by kitten on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 07:30:12 PM EST

A fancy word for "daydreaming".
mirrorshades radio - darkwave, synthpop, industrial, futurepop.
Ch'an (Zen) Buddhism (4.71 / 7) (#39)
by demi on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 08:49:46 PM EST

I've always preferred fucking, or masturbation, to meditation. Nevertheless my life was changed by exposure to Buddhism sometime in my late teenage years.

I was introduced to Ch'an by the writing of Upasaka Charles Luk, and especially the wonderful book The Transmission of the Mind Outside the Teaching (out of print), which is far removed from the "self-discovery and stress relief for yuppies" genre. The Northern School of Ch'an is more dialectic than other schools, and an understanding of the history of Buddhism and the Ming and Yuan dynasties in China helps a lot to appreciate the writings of the patriarchs.

I was never one to recite koans or epigraphs but I think the playfulness of the language of Ch'an, when contrasted with its deep and focused context, describes the spiritual, intellectual, and physical balance that I have since tried to achieve in most every aspect of my life. Transmission was a good introduction to reading Ch'an because it gives footnotes that only help you part of the way - it stops short of trying to explain the meaning of things that is helpful for beginners but detrimental in the long term. A lot of time had to be invested in learning the historical and religious contexts just for the annotations to make sense, which then made me understand why some masters were so reticent to translate anything or undertake an "introduction" to their work (until the 1960's explosion in Eastern mysticism at least).

I'm not really an expert in the area but at least I can say that students of Zen that stress external factors like meditation posture and internal factors like koans are trying too hard to achieve a proficiency in something that will give a reward. That's a really modern approach to Zen that I am glad I did not take.

In case you doubt .... (4.00 / 2) (#46)
by drblubgut on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 09:41:33 PM EST

Spend 5 min sitting still trying to do only count to 20 everytime you think of somthing elce or start to fidget start over.

5 min.. when your done.. you'll know there is somthing to be said for meditation.

Buddhism, the Total Package (4.70 / 10) (#48)
by radghast on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 10:07:47 PM EST

It is quite possible to practice zazen as stress relief, and many people do it. Without the rest of the package, however, it tends to get tedious.

Zen is a religion or a philosophy, depending upon the practitioner. Sitting in zazen will make you more conscious of the present and teach you to let go of distractions such as thoughts, feelings, and pain. It does not make them go away -- in fact, if you try to force thoughts away while sitting, you start down the nihilistic path. (Nihilism can be a dangerous error in all forms of Buddhism.) Instead, you allow thoughts and feelings to arise and depart, much like watching a wave break on the shore. Learning to do this takes years, during which time you've become more conscious of all of your aches, pains, noisy mind, fickle feelings, and reactiveness. This is where it gets tedious without the total package.

You've probably heard the expression 'no self' in relation to Buddhism. Buddhism is not removing one's ego to result in 'no self' -- it is the idea that your 'self' is solely the result of many streams of cause and effect (also known as karma) at this present time. Buddhism teaches that there is nothing static about you -- all is dynamic. Practicing Buddhism means learning to let go of the illusion of a static self and focus in the present moment only.

Other teachings, such as impermanence, deal with the unsatisfactoriness of life. Because everything is dynamic, nothing lasts and nothing remains the same. Suffering results when we think of something that is dynamic as static and grow attached to this concept -- whether that something causes pleasure or pain. All things arise and depart. Sitting in zazen teaches you how to approach this.

There is much more to the total package; its basis is called 'the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path'. If you decide to learn more about it, you'll find that they are deeply interrelated with the concept of sitting in zazen, and it will explain much. The nice thing about Buddhism is that it can be practiced as a philosophy for those who aren't looking for a religion or who already have one -- it's become quite popular with both Christian and Jewish individuals. Catholics already have some integration of traditions in the works of Thomas Merton.

On a different note, there was an article in the NYTimes (free registration) about the roots of Modern Buddhism -- the form that is popular in the West. Interesting read to see what the motivations were.

"It remains to be seen if the human brain is powerful enough to solve the problems it has created." -- Dr. Richard Wallace
Does anyone know if scientific research has been (3.00 / 3) (#54)
by Big Sexxy Joe on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 11:09:48 PM EST

done on this topic?

I'm like Jesus, only better.
Democracy Now! - your daily, uncensored, corporate-free grassroots news hour
Your cups are too full (4.37 / 8) (#57)
by genman on Mon Oct 28, 2002 at 11:58:34 PM EST

A university professor went to visit a famous Zen master. While the master quietly served tea, the professor talked about Zen. The master poured the visitor's cup to the brim, and then kept pouring. The professor watched the overflowing cup until he could no longer restrain himself. "It's overfull! No more will go in!" the professor blurted.

"You are like this cup," the master replied, "How can I show you Zen unless you first empty your cup."

Moments of Zen (4.33 / 3) (#58)
by Juppon Gatana on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 12:21:37 AM EST

I do not practice Zen meditation or philosophy, but I find it very interesting and may move into experimentation sometime soon.

Something interesting that I've found in my own life is that reading brings me to the most zen-like state I normally encounter. I wouldn't be surprised if many others experience this as well, as I assume it is natural. I notice that during a good book I can become completely engrossed in a story, losing all sense of self, my surroundings, and any temporally extraneous stimulation. I then read solely for the act itself without anticipating or reflecting upon the story. It's almost a false Zen in that it, of course by Zen standards, is an illusion (perhaps within an illusion and so on), but I imagine the feeling of appreciation for the now with no concern for anything else is a strong facet of a Zen-led life.

I find myself much more able to achieve a similar frame of mind while walking, particularly at night. I lived in Manhattan for 18 years prior to entering college, but I now live (for a few months at least) in rural Minnesota, and enjoy the nature out here greatly. As much as I love The City, not having filth and grit blown into your face when you go for a walk is a charming aspect of rural America. It leaves me a lot more open to think clearly, or not think at all. Analyzing it now, I think I revert more to the child's mind. Walking across campus at midnight, I usually look up and smile and allow myself simply to be happy. When I'm in the right state, I generally don't think, and I certainly don't worry about things in the future and past.

- Juppon Gatana
能ある鷹は爪を隠す。
(Nou aru taka wa tsume wo kakusu.)
Family, religion, meditation (3.66 / 6) (#59)
by Rademir on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 01:12:22 AM EST

My dad was always totally down on religion while i was growing up, but i remember one time sitting in the back of the car trying to follow his instructions on how to meditate (yeah yeah, maybe he was just trying to keep the kid busy and quiet). He didn't practice it himself, but he occasionally said positive things about it.

More recently, i went to a meditation training through dhamma.org (aka Goenka), a meditation school that originated in Myanmar, and started teaching to laypeople again only in the last century. A ten-day silent sit is the only way they'll let you start, and it's free. Afterward you may make a donation, in the spirit of offering it freely to others. Also, teachers and staff are all volunteers. I found this integrity very attractive.

Philosophy-wise, there was more than i could have stomached when i was atheist, but it really wasn't that much, and it was presented clearly enough that it actually helped me to come up with my own explanations for why meditation works. They also stressed that the path to wisdom is through your own experience, not by just accepting ideas (so it must be true :). Practice, practice, practice.



Consciousness is our Oxygen Challenge


Let me guess... (2.50 / 4) (#60)
by Hired Goons on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 01:13:07 AM EST

there is no spoon.
You calling that feature a bug? THWAK
I'll pass.... (1.90 / 10) (#61)
by faustus on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 02:33:41 AM EST

...I'm not a fan of any cult, including this one. I have had first hand experiences with two horrible, and closely inter-related cults known as Scientology and libertarianism. Both of these "religions" were designed to squeeze money out of nerds with low self-esteems. They that found it comforting to follow a cult based on science fiction because it conveniently vindicated their long held beliefs that SF is the highest art form known to man, second only to their posters of Natalie Portman.

Self (3.25 / 4) (#62)
by bigchris on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 03:45:10 AM EST

Selfishness diminishes; compassion and wisdom come. Zen is about having time for the self. By reaching the deepest part of you, you can notice what brings you happiness and unhappiness and change your way of looking at things. It will reveal what you are letting crowd your thoughts, how hungry you are, if you are sleepy, and other changes in your body, making you mindful of the self.

How can selfishness diminish when you are focusing on only yourself?

for a serious reader only (4.16 / 6) (#65)
by tealeaf on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 04:34:29 AM EST

Suffering consciously strengthens resolve.

Once you become resolute, barriers vanish.

All the technique and skill in the world cannot explain this fact.  In the end, what you want is wisdom and not a mental skill.

There is no shortcut.


My biggest regret (4.00 / 2) (#70)
by rasilon on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 06:08:14 AM EST

Is that the one skill I posses but cannot teach is meditation. I can and have taught the ways of war, I've taught many recruits to their rifles and soldiers to use them better, but I cannot teach the ways of peace. The zen that can be spoken is not the true zen and at that point I'm stumped. I used to try, but I would invariably end up suggesting that they find a better teacher.

for me... (4.00 / 4) (#73)
by boxed on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 06:47:46 AM EST

...the most important thing has been the realization that zazen is just a way to recognize the now so that you can keep this state of mind at all times. I practically never do zazen anymore because I meditate while walking, sitting, sleeping, talking, working, fucking, sleeping. A cat always keeps the every day mind, it is only us humans that learn to be confused.

How utterly disgusting. (1.66 / 9) (#78)
by tkatchev on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 08:27:17 AM EST

Thanks for demonstrating exactly what people mean when they speak of "the downfall of Western Civilization".

Y'all disgust me.

   -- Signed, Lev Andropoff, cosmonaut.

fhotg says: (4.50 / 2) (#83)
by fhotg on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 08:56:10 AM EST

Better to meditate than to sit around and do nothing !
~~~
Gitarren für die Mädchen -- Champagner für die Jungs

interesting (4.00 / 2) (#93)
by shrubbery on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 11:03:51 AM EST

Alot of this sounds very, very close to the state achieved through hypnosis. In hypnosis, the body and mind is very relaxed but is still aware of its environments. Its also very volunitary as opposed to its common conception. I wouldn't be surprised if the practice of "self-hyponosis" and "meditation" are two names for basically the same thing.

Critics. (4.37 / 8) (#103)
by watchmaker on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 12:55:20 PM EST

About zen, or any other form of buddhist philosophy, everything I am about to say is true. Or maybe it's false. And every critic who criticized this as new age bullshit is absolutely right. Or perhaps wrong.

It doesn't matter. And nobody here has grasped that.  

What we're talking about here is a worldview. A set of explanations that a person uses to explain the way the world works.

There are people that have the worldview that there is a mystical being sitting up in the clouds somewhere watching down benevolently. This being either sent a man named Jesus as his prophet. Or perhaps it was later a man named Mohammed. Or maybe there was no prophet at all.

In my world view, that's wrong, because there is not a single shred of provable evidence that any of that is true. But guess what, it's just my personal world view. It's how I describe the world, how I make sense of how the world is put together.

So, is Christianity a cult? The definition is too broad. Are the Presbyterians a cult? Not likely. I grew up in the Presbyterian church, and it's about as non cult like as you can imagine. Were the Branch Davidians of David Koresh a cult? Absolutely. He used Christian symbolism and mythology to draw his victims in closer.

Is Buddhism a cult? Is Buddhism even a religion? According to Merriam Webster's dictionary, religion is, among other things...


1) : the service and worship of God or the supernatural

And, just so we're clear, Supernatural is...

1 : of or relating to an order of existence beyond the visible observable universe; especially : of or relating to God or a god, demigod, spirit, or devil

So, is Buddhism a religion? Well, just like our Christianity question above, it's too broad of a question.

The Buddha was a man. A prince named Gautama Siddhartha. He wasn't a god, he wasn't a mystical being in the sense of the definition of the supernatural above. I don't know of a Buddhist belief structure that makes him anything other than a "Great man who changed the world around him." You could apply the same definition to Socrates, or Pasteur, or hell, even John Coletrane, that doesnt make them gods.

So from that, no, Buddhism is not a religion.

When Buddhist teachings began to spread to other parts of the world, it was retaught and assimilated into other world views. And so, you ended up with Tibetan Buddhism which believes in reincarnation. It's the Buddhist philosophies of non self, dukkha, the eightfold path, and the like, combined with the ancient Tibetan belief system of reincarnation. I'd call this a religion, because it passes the supernatural smell test. But in this case it's the reincarnation that is the religion. The fact that they use Buddhist meditation techniques has little to do with it.

Are there true buddhist cults? Many believe that Soka Gakkai qualifies. I have no opinion, as I haven't read enough on both sides to make a clear judgement.

I recently began exploring Theravada and Zen Buddhist literature. I highly recommend Thich Nhat Hanh's The Heart of the Buddha's Teaching or Steve Hagen's Buddhism: Plain and Simple. I have begun sitting in zazen recently. I have resisted joining a local center and finding a teacher because, well, despite all that I said above, I hate organized "religion", and it's been a struggle to overcome that and accept Buddhism. I have traded some emails with a local Theravada instructor, but haven't yet attended a gathering.

So, does it work? Yes. I sit, rather non traditionally, cross legged on a couch, with the soles of both feet touching each other, knees out to the side. I have bad knees, and this is the only way I am comfortable.

I close my eyes and breathe deeply and slowly, counting each breath, up to 100, and then backwards to zero. I pay attention to my breathing , or to the sound of the furnace, or the image of a swinging gate. Anything. Stray thoughts still arise, but I don't force them away. I acknowledge their existence and try to determine where they came from.

When sports reporters interview American Football quarterbacks as rookies, the players often say something to the effect that they are improving because "The game is slowing down for me." That is, they are becoming more aware of their task, their role, the patterns of defenders on the field in front of them, and it's as if the world moves slower, they can better make quick decisions.

That's EXACTLY how I feel after a successful session of sitting. I am so in tune with the world around me that it's as if it has slowed down.

It's not mystical, it's not supernatural, Jebus isn't granting me strength, I haven't aligned my aura to my eleventh descending chakra with pyramids and crystals. I've used my own will power to increase the ability of my conscious brain to deal with the world around me.

So, to those of you scoff, that's fine. You're right, and I'm wrong. Or is it the other way around?


Confused soul (5.00 / 1) (#114)
by Hoo00 on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 05:23:46 PM EST

Zen makes me "a ghost in a shell" :). I am so focused in my mind (at lease i think i was) that i forgot about my body. Sometimes the sense is so strong that i am wondering what the heck is this life about attaching to this body and reacting to this world like that... If you believe in god, you still can go to heaven. At least you believe that you can, since i am a non-believer. An end in zen is to disappear from reality and be nothing (what else is there to support an alternative reality?). Perhaps one day when I am old, this would be a bliss, as the body is giving up anyway. There is not much of a difference. If wisdom is good sense and true understanding and stupidity is falsehood and misunderstood, then zen is nonsense and complete blank. Zen is a return to balance. You can be wise and still be misguided. I guess i need more of zen myself for saying such nonsense. Or am i having too much of nonsense?

further reading (4.50 / 2) (#118)
by deadkarma on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 07:36:29 PM EST

If you want to understand Zen a little better, maybe this website will help:

http://www.do-not-zzz.com

Concentration (1.66 / 3) (#125)
by shwag on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 09:51:30 PM EST

I recommend this for the serious student. http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0879800232/qid=1035946634/sr=8-1/r ef=sr_8_1/104-6152615-6378329?v=glance&n=507846 Concentration a Guide to Mental Mastery by Mouni Sadhu

Concentration. (3.00 / 1) (#126)
by shwag on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 09:53:09 PM EST

I recommend this for the serious student.

Amazon book link here.

Concentration a Guide to Mental Mastery by Mouni Sadhu

Introductory materials? (4.00 / 1) (#129)
by htonl on Tue Oct 29, 2002 at 10:15:49 PM EST

Hey, nice article. Do you have any introductory type links to zen philosophy? Electronic or hardcopy materials are fine. I spent all quarter studying western modernity and I'm looking to break into some eastern philosophy to balance it out.

An important point. . . (3.80 / 5) (#160)
by Fantastic Lad on Wed Oct 30, 2002 at 06:17:17 PM EST

There is an element of Zen Buddhism which I consider perhaps to be one of the most important to consider when starting on this path. . .

It was mentioned briefly by an earlier poster, but not in enough detail. I would like to clarify, if I may. . .

One of the key features of this type of meditation is well advertised; to clear the mind, to become transparent, to forget the self.

Students can take this in either a positive or a negative direction.

I believe that, in the positive, (and that this was the original intent of the practice), is the effort to shut off what don Juan of the Carlos Castaneda books described as the internal dialogue.

The internal dialogue was first described to a young Carlos. . .

"You think and talk too much. You must stop talking to yourself."
"What do you mean?"
"You talk to yourself too much. You're not unique at that. Every one of us does that. We carry on an internal talk. Think about it. Whenever you are alone, what do you do?"
"I talk to myself."
"What do you talk to yourself about?"
"I don't know; anything, I suppose."
"I'll tell you what what we talk to ourselves about. We talk about our world. In fact we maintain our world with our internal talk."
"How do we do that?"
"Whenever we finish talking to ourselves the world is always as it should be. We renew it, we kindle it with life, we uphold it with our internal talk. Not only that, but we also choose our paths as we talk to ourselves. Thus we repeat the same choices over and over until the day we die, because we keep on repeating the same internal talk over and over until the day we die. A warrior is aware of this and strives to stop his talking. This is the last point you have to know if you want to live like a warrior."

--Carlos Castaneda, A Separate Reality.

And then several years later. . .
I told don Juan that I had practiced the technique for years without noticing any change, but I had expected none anyway. One day, however, I had the shocking realization that I had just walked for about ten minutes without having said a single word to myself.

I mentioned to don Juan that on that occasion I also became cognizent that stopping the internal dialogue involved more than merely curtailing the words I said to myself. My entire thought processes had stopped and I had felt I was practically suspended, floating. A sensation of panic had ensued from that awareness and I had to resume my internal dialogue as an antidote.

"I've told you that the internal dialogue is what grounds us," don Juan said. "The world is such and such or so and so, only because we talk to ourselves about it being such and such or so and so."

Don Juan explained that the passageway into the world of sorcery opens up after the warrior has learned to shut off the internal dialogue. "To change our idea of the world is the crux of sorcery," he said. "And stopping the internal dialogue is the only way to accomplish it. The rest is just padding.

--Carlos Castaneda,Tales of Power

It seems to me that the goal of Zen Buddhist meditation is the same as the Toltec practice of stopping the internal dialogue. From this point, full awareness can be reached.

Now, this is the kind of thing that the power elite of the world, (governments and old-money families), find to be the stuff of nightmare; People rising up from their shackles through awareness? Oh my! In any case, I tend to believe that for these kinds of reasons, corruptions are introduced into spiritual practices in order to prevent and confuse people in their seeking. Christ's teachings were thoroughly distorted and sullied by the powers which shortly followed him. And I would be very surprised if the same is not true of Buddha and others.

In the case of Zen meditation, I regularly see the following problem. . .

To 'empty the mind', to 'forget the body', to 'vanish from the world,' can be twisted very easily to achieve a very unhealthy state. That of withdrawing. Souls can reach upwards or downwards. To reach upwards, means to continually question, explore, to accumulate knowledge and wisdom. To grow like this is to grow in a powerful, spiritual way, and stopping the internal dialogue in order to allow our description of the world to collapse and see directly the energy which makes up our reality can offer a huge leap forward in understanding everything, as it breaks us away from one perspective and allows many, many others. This is what is known as 'Seeing.' Any time our ability to see new things, or the same things in new ways, increases our knowledge and spirit likewise grow.

However, some souls find the struggle of existence, (and indeed, eternal existence through many reincarnative lives), a tiresome and even horrifying concept. For these types of people, there is the strong desire to collapse the soul into lower and lower forms. Essentially, to crawl back into the womb and go back to sleep. To become, what is known in some circles, as primal matter. This is the only known way, (according to my knowledge, anyhow), in which a soul can truly be destroyed, and as such, it is fiercely sought after by those who find existence unbearable. (Though primarily this is done on a subconscious level, the decision perhaps having been made pre-incarnation where full access to one's total knowledge base from all lived lived is available.)

The practice of emptying the mind and forgetting the body and the world through Zen meditation can just as easily facilitate this kind of regression of awareness; the undoing and giving up of knowledge, one's very spiritual essence.

Now, the problem is that these two paths are rarely made explicit, and indeed, the 'fruits along the path' of each direction are often held up as high examples of what a seeker should strive for without making any differentiation at all between them. I remember reading with great distaste the story of the Zen 'master' who was so successful in his meditation that he wasted away and died. The point that I wanted to make with this post is that students could find benefit in distinguishing between these two paths.

There is a great deal more one could discuss on this subject, but that's enough for now.

-Fantastic Lad

Zazen: The Fundamental Meditation of Zen | 208 comments (168 topical, 40 editorial, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort:

kuro5hin.org

[XML]
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. The Rest © 2000 - Present Kuro5hin.org Inc.
See our legalese page for copyright policies. Please also read our Privacy Policy.
Kuro5hin.org is powered by Free Software, including Apache, Perl, and Linux, The Scoop Engine that runs this site is freely available, under the terms of the GPL.
Need some help? Email help@kuro5hin.org.
My heart's the long stairs.

Powered by Scoop create account | help/FAQ | mission | links | search | IRC | YOU choose the stories!